Page 3 of Proof of Diabolic Puzzle of 02/20/07

The following is page three of an illustrated proof for the Tough Sudoku of February 20, 2007.

This is page three of a multi-page proof for this puzzle. The pages will come out gradually over the next few hours, as they are created. The general theme of each page will be slightly different, as the puzzle progresses through various degrees of technique difficulty.

You may need to refer to previous blog pages to understand this proof. Links to these pages are found to the right, under Previous Entries.

The information on the following blog pages is required to understand this page:

The illustrations of forbidding chains used in this proof will share the same key:

  • black lines = strong links
  • red lines = weak links
  • black circles connected with black lines = multi-part strong sets
  • candidates crossed out in red = candidates proven false

Conventions used in writing Forbidding Chains

The following convention will be used when presenting complex or Advanced Forbidding Chains:

  • A == B -- C ==1 {D == E -- F ==1 G} -- H == I
  • subscripts will be used to label a stong link that is conditional, meaning in the case above, for example, that {C,F,G} form a native strong set
  • {}'s will contain a sub chain. Generally, subchains are conditional. In other words, the entire sub-chain either exists, or it does not exist, dependent upon the subscripted internal links. In the case shown above, both D and G must forbid H in order for the sub-chain within the brackets to be a valid piece of the chain. Whether or not the sub-chain is eventually proven false or true makes no difference to the validity of the larger chain, as with any other Boolean used in the chain.
  • As in all properly written forbidding chains, one can read the chain either left to right or right to left
Suppose in the example above that one substitues {D == E -- F ==1 G} with the Boolean Z. Then one would have:
  • A == B -- C == Z -- H == I
In all cases, Z must be true if C is false.

In most cases, both endpoints of Z must forbid H. However, in the special case whereas Z is a wrap-around or nice loop chain, as long as at least one of the newly proven strong sets within Z forbids H, all is good. This is no different than using Almost Locked Sets within a Chain, except that there is no requirement that a subchain be only a conditionally Locked Set.

Realizing the validity of using any Forbidding Chain as a Boolean within a Forbidding Chain is the primary inspiration of all Net or 3-D techniques. One may see them represented otherwise, but a strict adherence to the manner in which I employ such chains keeps the chain integrity in both directions, and allows tremendous power in writing complex techniques such as Sue de Cox with Forbidding Chains

Back to the puzzle

A Hidden Almost Locked Set used in a chain

Above, a4 must be either 7 or 9. If a4≠79 then

  • b6=9 and a5=7 =>
  • b1≠9 and i5≠7 =>
  • i1=9 and i1=7
This idea can be presented in a forbidding chain:
  • {Hidden pair 719 at a4b6} ==1 a5=7 -- i5=7 == i1=7 -- i1=9 == b1=9 -- b6=9 == a4=9 => a4=79
In this case, the depth of the step is 4, as it considers exactly 4 native strong sets:
  1. a4,b6 = 9
  2. b1,i1 = 9
  3. i5,i1 = 7
  4. a4,a5,b6 = 7
It may appear upon first inspection that one is using 5 strong sets, but the chain actually uses the first strong set that I listed twice. There is no reason not to do that!

Finally, one may think that the chain above is a wrap-around or nice loop chain. This is an error. The endpoints of the chain are not in conflict with each other. a4=9 does not prevent b6=7, and a4=9, b6=7 is one of two possibilities meant by Hidden Pair 79 at a4,b6.

The chain above has been available for quite some time. I choose to present it now, since the chains that I will present on this page are meant to be very important to solving this puzzle.

A very tough chain to understand

Depth 6 complex chain

Hopefully, I can make the graphic above clear. The easiest way to understand, at first, is probably with a contradiction proof:

  • Suppose e7=1
  • => e12≠1
  • Now, if e12≠1 we have the following forbidding chain:
    • b1=6 == d1=6 -- d1=1 == f23=1 -- f4=1 == f4=9 -- a4=9 == a2=9 forbids b1=9
  • but, b1≠9 => i1=9 ==> i7≠9 => i7=1. This contradicts e7=1
One can write this idea as a Forbidding Chain:
  • e12=1 ==1 {b1=6 == d1=6 -- d1=1 ==1 f23=1 -- f4=1 == f4=9 -- a4=9 == a2=9} -- b1=9 == i1=9 -- i7=9 == i7=1 => e7≠1
The six strong sets considered are:
  1. i7 = 19
  2. bi1 = 9
  3. bd1 = 6
  4. f4 = 19
  5. a24 = 9
  6. d1,e12,f23 = 1
Of these strong sets, the ones that are indicated by the puzzle mark-up as points of interest are all of them except the last one. To find such a chain, one has to think only one strong set outside the box.

This elimination is a set up for the next elimination, which is not any easier.

Another very tough chain to understand

Depth 7 complex chain

Again, it is probably easier to understand this chain through a contradiction analysis:

  • Suppose h9=5
  • => h9≠46 => h8=6 => h8≠4 => h7=4 => e7≠4 => the existence of this chain:
    • g9=5 == g9=1 -- i7=1 == i7=9 -- e7=9 == e7=3 -- e4=3 == g4=3 forbids g4=5
  • g4≠5 => h4=5 contradicts h9=5
The 5s and 1s are wrapped all up with each other here, so one can consider the exact same sets and forbid g9=1, or g4=5, or add one set and forbid h4=17. As a forbidding chain, the graphic I choose to illustrate can be written:
  • {Hidden Pair 416 at h89} ==1 h7=4 -- e7=4 ==2 {g9=5 == g9=1 -- i7=1 == i7=9 -- e7=9 ==2 e7=3 -- e4=3 == g4=3 -- g4=5 == h4=5} => h9≠5
The seven strong sets considered are
  1. gh4 = 5
  2. eg4 = 3
  3. e7 = 349
  4. i7 = 19
  5. g9 = 15
  6. h789 = 4
  7. h89 = 6
Of these, only h789=4 and e7=349 are not indicated as likely suspects in the puzzle mark-up. However, the entire box h8 has been indicated as a possible area of investigation for some time. Finding such a chain may take some practice. One may have to learn the standard chains well. Only after such study did the more complex chains become less obscure for me. I suppose there are some relevant banalities that deal with human motor skills....

After making the indicated elimination, finally some cells can be solved:

  • g9 = 5% box & row
  • h4 = 5% box, row, & column
  • i5 = 7% box
  • h1 = 7% box, row, & column
Much work to get to UP 33!

Hidden Pair 79

Hidden Pair 79

Graphically illustrated as a forbidding chain, one can find Hidden Pair 79 at a4b6. One may find the naked triple 235 at a5, c56 easier to spot. In either event, b6≠235. This solves one more cell:

  • b8 = 5% column
Having arrived at UP 34, it probably is time to consider a new, or a completely refreshed, puzzle mark-up. The struggle to solve this one continues on yet another page!

Please visit the next blog page on this puzzle to see some more steps!

1 Comment
Indicate which comments you would like to be able to see

Steve : if you do have a few minutes at some stage I'd be much appreciative if could you clarify what follows for me :
I never have any difficulty looking at your diagrams (which are always very clear) and following the eliminations. To that extent I very often don't bother to read the chains More...
18/May/07 1:40 AM
 |  |
Please Log in to post a comment.

Not a member? Joining is quick and free.
As a member you get heaps of benefits.
Click Here to join.
You can also try the Chatroom (No one chatting right now - why not start something? )
Check out the Sudoku Blog     Subscribe
Members Get Goodies!
Become a member and get heaps of stuff, including: stand-alone sudoku game, online solving tools, save your times, smilies and more!
Previous Entries

07/Jan/07 Ywing Styles
06/Jan/07 Definitions
31/Dec/06 Y wings
27/Dec/06 Coloring
11/Dec/06 Beginner Tips
Check out all the Daily Horoscopes
Welcome our latest Members
glenrose from Qld Sunshine Coast
turtle from california
Annie from Ireland
Member's Birthdays Today
CP from Canberra, JennieT from Oh/USA
Friends currently online
Want to see when your friends are online? Become a member for free.

Network Sites

Melbourne Bars Find the Hidden Bars of Melbourne
Free Crossword Puzzles Play online or print them out. 2 new crosswords daily.
Jigsaw Puzzles Play online jigsaw puzzles for free, with new pictures everyday
Sliding Puzzle Play online with your own photos
Flickr Sudoku Play sudoku with pictures from Flickr
Kakuro Play Kakuro online!
Wordoku Free Wordoku puzzles everyday.
Purely Facts Test your General Knowledge.
Pumpkin Carving Pattern Free halloween pumpkin carving patterns.