Easter Monster Round 3


The following is page three of my campaign versus the Easter Monster.

If this is your first visit to this blog, WELCOME!!

Previous blog pages may be helpful. Links to these pages are found to the right, under Previous Entries. Specifically, it may be helpful to have visited the following four pages first:

The illustrations of steps shown in this proof will share this key:

  • black line = strong inference performed upon a set (strong link)
  • red line = weak inference performed upon a set (weak link)
  • black containers define a partioning of a strong set(s)
  • candidates crossed out in red = candidates proven false
  • Orange labels mark derived inferences
Please be aware that, for me, strong and weak need not be mutually exclusive properties.

Previous information

Previously, the following derived strong and weak inference groups were proven.

  • Each set in Group Z below contains exactly one truth:
    • (27)r2c13, (27)r2c56, (16)r2c56,(16)r2c79
    • (16)c8r13,(16)c8r45,(27)c8r45,(27)c8r79
    • (27)r8c79,(27)r8c45,(16)r8c45,(16)r8c13
  • Group X is a strong inference set(sis): (2)[r8c5,r5c2,r8c7]
Before making the next elimination, I will add two more such groups.

Group U - using an Almost Almost Two String Kite

The following sets are derived sis U

  • [(1):r2c5,r6c2,r7c2]
  • [(1)r2c5,(1)r6c2,(6)r8c1]

Group U - an almost squared two string kite

By now, hopefully the idea is clear. Write the conclusion and the appendages that could prevent the conclusion as a strong inference set. The proof could look like:

  • (1): [r2c5=r6c2]=[r8c5=r4c5-r6c6=r6c3]-r8c3=r7c2 => [(1)r2c5,r67c2] is a sis.
  • Using Z:(1)r8c3=(6)r8c1 => [(1)r2c5,(1)r6c2,(6)r8c1] is a sis.

Group T - using an AAA Y Wing Style.

The following set is derived sis T

  • [(4)r3c2,(4)r8c1,(4)r8c7,(14)r8c3]
This one seems quite a stretch - 3 almostings. The previous deduction U in conjuction with Z made looking for this one seem logical at the time.

Group T - an almost cube Y Wing Style

The AIC justification reads:

  • sis[(4):r3c2,r8c17]=[(4)r8c3=(4)r8c9-(4)r3c9=(4-5)r3c1=(5)r1c3]-(5)r8c3=(14)r8c3 =>
  • sis[(4)r3c2,(4)r8c137,(1)r8c3]

13x13 TM using derived and native strong inference sets

Step 2c

Too messy to fully graph step 2c

The graphic above does not dispay all the information used. I graphed some of the main ideas. Again, a Triangular Matrix below will serve as both the proof and illustration of the elimination.

2B1 r2c1 r3c2
2X r8c5r5c2r8c7
Z 2r56c27r6c2
1U r2c5r6c2 r7c2
Z 1r8c36r8c1
T 4r3c24r8c7 1r8c34r8c14r8c3
4r4 c3c1
4r3 c2 c1 c9
4r7 c23 c9c5
r9c2 64 8
8r7 c5c23c6
2c1 r2 r4 r6
2c6 r23 r7 r6

Long, messy, and a tad convoluted. I suspect 'tis the nature of this beast. r2c5≠2 lets us make some easy eliminations.

Steps 2d, 2e.

Easy stuff

Above we have two steps illustrated:

  • 2d: Using Z, (2=7)r2c56, note r2c5 now is void of [27] => r2c6≠16
  • 2e: (2):r4c5=r8c5-r8c7=r7c8 => r4c8<>2

Step 2f. Single candidate fish.

Relatively Easy almost symmetric elimination

This elimination is symmetric to V done on candidate 1. The appendage has been eliminated, so the derivation makes the elimination. As AIC:

  • (6): [r2c9=r2c5-[r6c1,r4c5]=[r4c89=r4c1-r56c2=r9c2-r9c6=r6c6] =>
  • sis(6):[r2c9,r4c89,r6c6] => r6c9≠6

At this point, the Almost Almost Naked Pair 39 at r6c79 caught my attention. Because of the super cell-like relationship (27)at r45c8, the potential for an odd Sue de Coq using super cells reared its head. If I could have found such an animal, it would have been very cool. Unfortunately, I was unequal to the task. Nevertheless, looking in that direction lead me directly to a fairly simple elimination (for this puzzle!).

Step 2g - a Three way pincer with candidate 2.

Interesting strong set with 2's

Above, I have graphed all the strong inference sets considered to make this elimination. After finding this elimination, I found numerous ways to reach the same elimination. Some are a bit quicker, but none as cool - imho. Placing all the weak links into the diagram proved difficult for me. The logic, as AIC, looks like this:

  • [2:r4c5=r8c5-r8c7=r7c6] =
  • [(2)r4c7-[(1)r4c7,(2)r5c8,(2)r6c7]
  • = Z(7)r4c8=(pair39)r6c79 &
  • = (1)r7c2-(1=6)r2c5-(6)r1c6=[(6):r6c6=r9c6-r9c2=r1c8]]
  • -(639=2)r6c1
  • reducing nicely to sis2g 2:[r4c5,r7c6,r6c1] => r6c6≠2
This is a tad messy to follow as AIC. It should be crystal clear as a Mixed Block Matrix.

The matrix below is called Mixed Block only becuase of the use of a contained Pigeonhole matrix - pair 39. To shorten the matrix, I treat this as one Boolean. This reduces the Matrix to a simple Triangular Matrix.

2c5 r4 r8
2c7 r6r8r4
Z 2r5c87r4c8
r6c79 27 pair39
1c7 r4 r2
r2c5 16
r4c1 2 396
6r6 r1r4 r9
6B7 c1 r9

As noted previously, this derives sis 2g 2[r4c5,r6c7,r4c1] => r6c6≠2.

This sis may be useful later.

One could justify the same elimination, considering the same strong inference sets, but thinking roughly in terms of

  • [naked triple 239]r6c179=
  • [(2=7)r56c8 - (7)r6c9=(6)r6c1-(6's) ... =(1)r4c7]
  • -(2)r4c7 = [skyscraper with 2's]
  • => sis2g => r6c6≠2

There are, as I noted, some other paths that consider only a few of the same strong inference sets. Those are also fairly interesting, but I lack the time to expose every possible elimination path.

This concludes this page. There remains many difficult eliminations, unless I find a simpler path before I publish. Hope springs eternal!.

If you have read this far, thanks for your patience!




Be the first to post a Comment
Indicate which comments you would like to be able to see

Please Log in to post a comment.

Not a member? Joining is quick and free.
As a member you get heaps of benefits.
Click Here to join.
You can also try the Chatroom (No one chatting right now - why not start something? )
Check out the Sudoku Blog     Subscribe
Members Get Goodies!
Become a member and get heaps of stuff, including: stand-alone sudoku game, online solving tools, save your times, smilies and more!
Previous Entries

07/Jan/07 Ywing Styles
06/Jan/07 Definitions
31/Dec/06 Y wings
27/Dec/06 Coloring
11/Dec/06 Beginner Tips
Check out all the Daily Horoscopes
Welcome our latest Members
PeeBee from Perth WA
Serban_L from Cluj
Grandmavickie from NJ
Member's Birthdays Today
Julie from IL, USA
Friends currently online
Want to see when your friends are online? Become a member for free.

Network Sites

Melbourne Bars Find the Hidden Bars of Melbourne
Free Crossword Puzzles Play online or print them out. 2 new crosswords daily.
Jigsaw Puzzles Play online jigsaw puzzles for free, with new pictures everyday
Sliding Puzzle Play online with your own photos
Flickr Sudoku Play sudoku with pictures from Flickr
Kakuro Play Kakuro online!
Wordoku Free Wordoku puzzles everyday.
Purely Facts Test your General Knowledge.
Pumpkin Carving Pattern Free halloween pumpkin carving patterns.